Odysseus and penelope s son, telemachos, now a typically moody teenager, gets a visit from the goddess athene who was always chummy with odysseus. There is perhaps nothing in the odyssey which has sustained such varied criticism as the recognition scenes between penelope and odysseus. Odysseuss recourting of penelope discussion question 1 follow the steps by which odysseus recourts or renegotiates his marriage relationship with penelope. Eurycleia wakes up penelope to tell her odysseus has returned and killed the suitors. Penelope doesnt believe her, thinking shes gone mad. Her cares make her somewhat flighty and excitable, however. Mar 14, 2016 the odyssey penelope and odysseus duration. Murray then the old dame went up to the upper chamber, laughing aloud, to tell her mistress that her dear husband was in the house. Book 23 is the next to last book of homer s odyssey. Odysseus bids phemius play wedding music so that the suitors kin will not suspect the slaughter but will think, rather, that penelope has chosen a husband. Odysseus, penelope, telemachus character analysis the odyssey. Character description of penelope from the book the odyssey. Odysseus and penelopes son, telemachos, now a typically moody teenager, gets a visit from the goddess athene who was always chummy with odysseus. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans.
The more she spoke, the more a deep desire for tears welled up inside his breast he wept as he held the wife he loved, the soul of loyalty, in his arms at last 463. The trunk of the olive tree so she too rejoiced, her gaze upon her husband, her white arms around him pressed although forever penelope is being compared to forever in this passage symbol the tree symbolizes the unity between penelope and odysseus and how. The gradual rapprochement between penelope and odysseus, stretching over several books of the odyssey, contains two major movements or sections, one in book 19 and one in book 23. It was destroyed when penelope cheated on odysseus with one of the suitors.
The greek warrior odysseus has returned home to ithaca after ten years fighting at troy and an additional ten years struggling to find his way home. What was penelope s test of odysseus in book 23 of the odyssey. In book 18 of the odyssey, irus the beggar walked into the palace and picked a fight with odysseus. Feb 18, 2015 odysseus of course is a little put off by the lack of response. Without revealing his true identity, he tries to convince penelope that odysseus is on his way home and susses out which of his servants are still loyal to the household and which have joined the suitors. Book 23 eurycleia goes upstairs to call penelope, who has slept through the entire fight.
Compare and contrast penelope to other women in the odyssey calypso, circe, and the sirens penelope loved by odysseus, mortal, wants odysseus to return home. May 31, 2015 to test whether odysseus is who he says he is, she instructs eurycleia to move the bed, which angers odysseus. Plot odysseus killing the suitors odysseus slaughtered his wife s suitors. Penelopes test of odysseus in book 23 of the odyssey. Jan 29, 20 the story has to do with the meeting of odysseus and penelope in book 19 of the odyssey. The odyssey in book 23, what instructions does penelope give to eruycleia on page 461. He sets out with telemachus, the swineherd, and the cowherd. In many respects this encounter is the point of greatest dramatic intensity in the entire poem, and at the heart of the scene is a dream penelopes dream of the twenty geese that are suddenly slaughtered by a mountain eagle.
Odysseus s recourting of penelope discussion question 1 follow the steps by which odysseus recourts or renegotiates his marriage relationship with penelope. Penelope s test of odysseus in book 23 of the odyssey. Book 23 of the odyssey begins after odysseus has cleaned the palace of the foulness of battle and fumigated it. Penelope brings out odysseus s bow, and telemachus tries and fails to string it three times. He tells penelope not to leave her room or receive any visitors. The nurse goes upstairs excited by the news and she wakes penelope telling her that her husband has returned. The nurse mentions the telltale boar tusk scar on odysseuss knee, but penelope. Penelope announces the contest and retrieves odysseus great backsprung bow from a secret storeroom deep in the palace. Odysseus is then bathed and dressed and seated before his wife who remains obstinate in her belief that he. She tells him to go looking for news of his missing father, so he heads to pylos to visit king nestor. Eurycleia the nurse happily runs to penelope s room and wakes her up. Book 23 is the next to last book of homers odyssey.
In book 22, odysseus kills penelopes suitors and in book 23 eurycleia, penelopes maidservant, awakens penelope, who has been sound asleep. Although for most of the book it seems that penelope has to wait passively at home while odysseus commands armies and battles monsters, by the end of the book their roles seem to converge. Book 23 eurycleia informs penelope of odysseus return and tells of his deeds, but penelope remains suspicious lest the stranger be some other or a god but not her husband. Now that he has restored honor to his household, odysseus must make amends to poseidon. Though penelope, as a woman, cannot gain glory in battle. In the odyssey, penelope waits twenty years for her husband to return from the trojan war. Summary and analysis book 21 odysseus strings his bow.
May 23, 2012 all of this leads me to homers odyssey, one of my favorite epic poems. The reason why the marriage of odysseus lasted is because penelope was a very talented wife and odysseus was a man worthy of her. We still have the families of the suitors to deal with. Penelopes test of odysseus in book 23 of the odyssey answers penelope was talking to odysseus and told her maid to move odysseus bed so this beggar odysseus could stay the night. How does this serve as a trick for odysseus and what does odysseus reaction prove. In book 22, odysseus kills penelope s suitors and in book 23 eurycleia, penelope s maidservant, awakens penelope, who has been sound asleep. The nurse mentions the telltale boar tusk scar on odysseus s knee, but penelope refuses to believe the story. Penelope tells her not to play tricks on her and eurykleia is surprised that penelope would joke about such a thing.
Her knees moved nimbly, but her feet trotted along beneath her. In book 23, what instructions does penelope give to. The battle is over, and the scene shifts to penelope, who has been hiding in. Penelope and odysseus first meet face to face in a long conversation that essentially takes up all of book 19. In her second test, penelope retrieved odysseus bow, stating she will marry the man who strings it and makes a perfect shot. At the manor, penelope tearfully embraces her son and asks what news he learned. Holding back from her husband, home at last for her after bearing twenty years of brutal struggle. Shes like an ancient greek martha stewart, without the pesky insider trading scandal. This will buy odysseus some time to keep the families from noticing that he has killed the suitors.
Now that the battle has ended and the house has been cleaned, good nurse eurycleia scurries up to penelope s quarters to tell her all that has happened. He gives penelope instructions not to leave her room or receive any visitors. Odysseus removes his rags, prays to apollo, and then shoots an arrow through antinouss throat. With odysseus disguised as a beggar, she asked him about odysseus travels, clothing and personality. Odysseus has spent 20 years trying to return to his home in ithaka after the end of the trojan war.
Students first reflect on what odysseus has gone through to get be reunited with penelope. And she always bring the best cupcakes at the bake sale. What was penelopes test of odysseus in book 23 of the. As much as penelope would like to believe that her husband has returned and vanquished the suitors, she is cautious and goes to the great. We have traversed many trials alongside our hero, odysseus. The story of penelope and odysseus and their drawnout reunion over the course of the last third of the odyssey is one of the most extensively studied portions of the homeric epics. Melantho, the disrespectful servant girl who sleeps with eurymachus, confronts the beggar odysseus once more. Penelope resists odysseus because she fears that the gods want to trick her into disloyalty.
On the other hand, any suggestion that penelope suspects or even recognizes that the beggar is odysseus, but wishes simply for him to prove that he is the same odysseus whose guile and cleverness dominates those around him, and whose intelligence naturally rules over men, is defeated by her sincere reluctance to reconcile with odysseus in book 23. To test whether odysseus is who he says he is, she instructs eurycleia to move the bed, which angers odysseus. Penelopes test of odysseus in book 23 of the odyssey answers. Give the reunion of odysseus and penelope, can the odyssey be. Dear wife, we have not yet reached the end of our troubles. In book twentythree eurycleia runs up to tell penelope that her husband has returned, and he has killed all the suitors. When penelope awoke and heard the news, she could not believe the old woman and accused her of playing tricks on her. What was penelopes test of odysseus in book 23 of the odyssey. Exactly how and when penelope recognizes her husband has been the subject of scholarly debate since hellenistic times. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the odyssey and what it means. Odysseus and penelope key events this resource contains. Odysseus instructs telemachus to gather the weapons and hide them where they will not be readily available to the suitors the next day.
The odyssey books 1720 summary and analysis gradesaver. Only a strong woman could sustain the stress, anxiety and confusion resulting from the chaos of a palace with a missing king whose fate is unknown. Odysseus, book 23, line 186190 and then he commands the maidservant to make him a separate bed to sleep alone. In book 23, what instructions does penelope give to eruycleia on page 461. A solution to the enigmas of ivory and horns, and the test of the bed john b. Penelopes role in the odyssey essay, the odyssey homer. One mainstream reading of this narrative controversy is the gradual recognition argumentin other words, that penelope recognizes odysseus gradually and by degrees, culminating in a moment of full recognition in odyssey 23 emlynjones, 2. She set up a great loom in her palace, and set to weaving a web of threads long and fine. For sport, telemachus attempts to string the bow and fails three times. Penelope suspects in book 19 that the beggar is her husband as the result of his answering, in great detail, her questions regarding the clothes and jewelry odysseus wore when he left ithaca twenty years earlier. Together, penelope and odysseus are the parents of one son, telemachus. The reunion of odysseus and penelope in the odyssey by b. Unlike poor echo and narcissus above, odysseus and his wife penelope do experience a happy ending. Penelope doesnt believe anything that eurycleia says, and she remains in disbelief even when she comes downstairs and sees her husband with her own eyes.
In book 23 of the odyssey, penelope sees odysseus without his disguise, but still refuses to believe it is really him. Penelope, virtuous wife of odysseus the role of women in. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in the odyssey, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. Penelope tested odysseus three times in the odyssey. Telemachus instead tells her to make a sacrifice to the gods to help them with their revenge. Odysseus and penelope are finally reunited, for real. He asserts that the bed cannot be moved since it was constructed from the trunk of an olive tree that was still embedded in the ground. While homer uses epic simile for a variety of purposes, epic similes can often be read with a view to larger narrative considerations, and the simile in odyssey 23.
Athena hides odysseus and telemachus in darkness so that no one sees them as they pass. The suitors, horrified, plead for mercy, blame antinous for their wrongdoings, and offer to repay all they have stolen. Odysseus shoots antinous through the throat just as the suitor is about to take a sip of wine. The odyssey by homer book 23 summary and analysis youtube. The book begins with penelope choosing not to recognize odysseus. Penelopes early recognition of odysseus 2006 words bartleby. The lovely queen told him all she had suffered at home, watching the detestable crowd of suitors, who on her account slaughtered many cattle and fat sheep, and emptied whole jars of wine. Apr 27, 2020 in the odyssey by the ancient bard homer, penelope is the wife of odysseus, the main character of the epic tale.
Even when eurycleia tells her that all the suitors are dead, penelope thinks some strange hero has come to deliver her, not her husband. This was her way of putting her husband to the test. While odysseus was purifying the hall downstairs, eurycleia went up to draw the good penelope from her chambers and to tell her that her husband was waiting for her downstairs. She tells her that the old beggar was odysseus and he killed all the suitors. When telemachos gets back, odysseus reveals himself to his son and then heads to the palace, still disguised as a beggar. Before he leaves the following dawn, odysseus tells penelope to stay with her maids in her room, because men might come to avenge the suitors.
Homer, odyssey book 23 theoi classical texts library. One important narrative ambiguity in the odyssey is the question of penelopes recognition of odysseus. Penelope does not believe that it is really her husband who has returned. And with that penelope sees her chance to test odysseus s identity. For this reason, odysseus, telemachus, and athena often prefer to leave her in the dark about matters rather than upset her. Penelopes refusal to reject the suitors could also be interpreted as indecisiveness, a passive stance that allows the suitors to spoil her husbands lands and disrespect his memory. Penelopes role in the odyssey the character of penelope in homers odyssey reflects the faithful wife who waits twenty years for the arrival of her husband. The story has to do with the meeting of odysseus and penelope in book 19 of the odyssey. Summary and analysis book 19 penelope and her guest. Athena cloaks odysseus and telemachus in darkness so that no one will see them as. Bill wiese man who went to hell 23 minutes in hell. Jun, 2017 in book 17, telemachus sneezes to distract his mother from recognizing odysseus, and athena also intervenes to distract penelope when odysseus disrobes to bathe. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Book 22 concludes the greek epic cycle, though fragments remain of the alternative ending of sorts known as the telegony. He also wants telemachus to gather the servants and the bard and stage a fake wedding feast so that any passersby do not suspect the slaughter that has taken place. Meanwhile, odysseus wants everyone to act as if there is a wedding and. Odysseus wants the people outside the palace to think that there s a wedding feast going on so that it wont seem strange that the suitors arent out and about in the town. He meets up with the fugitive theoklymenos in town and brings him home, where they. Odysseus is here, and has come home, late though his coming has been, and. Its surprising that she manages to get any of that done, though, since she seems to spend most of. Summary and analysis book 23 the great rooted bed summary now that the battle has ended and the house has been cleaned, good nurse eurycleia scurries up to penelopes. The odyssey books 23 24 summary the odyssey by homer books 23 24 summary and analysis. Odysseus gently suggests that the prince leave his parents to work things out. When i thought about why odysseus preferred penelope to the goddess calypso and circe, for that matter it occurred to me that one difference between a goddess and a mortal is that a mortal can sin while a goddess.
For her final test, she requested the movement of their. Eurycleia tells penelope that odysseus has finally come home and killed the suitors. Awake, penelope, dear child, that with thine own eyes thou mayest see what thou desirest all thy days. Homers epic poem the odyssey tells the story of odysseus, greek hero of the trojan war, and his adventures at sea during his travel home.
Many details in the narrative and dialogue of the odyssey depict a penelope who is oblivious to, or at least unsure of, odysseus s identity until he has successfully passed her test of the marriage bed in book 23. Odysseus removes his rags, prays to apollo, and then shoots an arrow through antinous s throat. Though she has not seen odysseus in twenty years, and despite pressure the suitors place on her to remarry, penelope never loses faith in her husband. When the nurse told penelope that her husband had finally returned home, penelope didnt believe her. He is about to succeed on his fourth try when odysseus privately signals him to back off. Back in ithaka, odysseus wife penelope is getting swarmed by a horde of unwanted suitors. The telegony aside, the last 548 lines of the odyssey, corresponding to book 24, are believed by many scholars to have been. He reveals himself to be the longabsent king of ithaca. Vlahos1 the meaning of penelope s remarks to odysseus, disguised as a stranger, that dreams that pass through the gate of ivory are false and without fulfillment while those that pass through the gate of horns are. The king kicks the table and scatters the food on the floor, and the food mingles with antinouss blood. Oct 09, 2018 welcome to another video on the great work of art that is homer s odyssey. Penelopes role in the odyssey essay, the odyssey homer on. Young men, my suitors now that the great odysseus has perished, wait, though you are eager to marry me, until i finish this web, so that my weaving will not be useless and wasted. The couple retires together and odysseus briefly recounts his.